Adventures of the Early Church …

DID THEY HAVE TO BE BAPTIZED TWICE
TO RECEIVE THE HOLY SPIRIT?

One sure mark of the primitive ecclesia of Christ was that it was Spirit-filled. The chronicle in the Scriptures that tells the church’s story could as well be called “Acts of the Holy Spirit” as well as “Acts of the Apostles.” They walked by the Spirit, were led by the Spirit, were taught by the Spirit, and were even comforted by the Spirit. And so we have imagery such as drinking of the Spirit, filled with the Spirit, being baptized of the Spirit, and even the pouring out of the Spirit. They thus thought in terms of “sowing to the Spirit” and “the fruit of the Spirit.” They realized that the Spirit could be grieved, resisted, and sinned against. The Spirit often monitored their labors by telling them where to go or not to go, so that when one reads as far as Acts 20 he is not surprised to learn that an apostle is “bound in the Spirit” to go to Jerusalem.

The Scriptures make it abundantly clear that the early Christians were recipients of the Holy Spirit. Paul tells the Galatians (3:3) that they had “begun in the Spirit” and that since they were sons “God has sent forth the Spirit of His Son into your hearts” (4:6). In Gal. 3:2 he tells them plainly that they had received the Spirit, so the only question was whether the Spirit had been given them through faith or by works of law. In the same letter he refers to their being “born according to the Spirit” (4:29), and so such “fruit of the Spirit” as love, joy and peace is expected.

Paul assures the Ephesians that they were “sealed with the Holy” Spirit of promise” when they became believers (1:13), and in 2:18 he states that their access to God was by means of that indwelling Spirit. They were, moreover, “strengthened with might through His spirit in the inner man” (3:16), and they were instructed to “keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace” (4:3). Strangely enough, even though they already possessed the Spirit they were told to “be filled with the Spirit” (5:18). This suggests that the heart of a believer, like a refreshing stream, can be filled and running over with the Spirit, and yet be filled even more, depending on the believer’s capacity and desire.

Hardly anything is clearer in Scripture than the presence of the Holy Spirit in the life of the believer. Ro. 5:5 refers to God’s love being poured out in our hearts “by the Holy Spirit who was given us,” and Ro. 8:9 strongly asserts that “if anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, he is not His.” But no passage is more reassuring than 1 Jn. 4:13: “By this we know that we abide in Him, and He in us, because He has given us of His Spirit.”

There can be no question, therefore, as to whether the early Christians believed that the Holy Spirit was with them and in them, even as Christ had promised. The question raised here is when did they receive the Holy Spirit, and was its reception dependent on some experience they had after becoming Christians, such as “the baptism of the Holy Spirit,” as is commonly claimed today? If some “Charismatics” today are correct, the early Christians had to be twice-baptized to be filled: with the Spirit. First in water, then in the Spirit, and there might be years between these.

Some of the verses already referred to indicate that in the early church they received the Holy Spirit when they believed and obeyed the gospel. Paul would never have argued with the Galatians as he did if they did not possess the Spirit when they became Christians: “Are you so foolish? Having begun in the Spirit, are you now being made perfect by the flesh?” He makes it equally clear in Eph, 1:13 that they were sealed with the Holy Spirit when they believed, while in Eph. 4:6 he names it exactly: they received the Spirit when they became sons of God.

One cannot study 2 Cor. 1:21-22 without concluding that one receives the Spirit when he becomes a Christian, for in those verses he names four things that happen: (1) God establishes the believer in ~Christ; (2) God anoints the believer; (3) God seals the believer; (4) God ;gives the Spirit to the believer. One may as well say that one becomes a:Christian and sometime afterward, maybe years, he is established in Christ as to say he becomes a Christian and afterward he may receive ithe Spirit. The natural interpretation of those verses would be that one [receives all four of these blessings when he becomes a Christian.
So we may conclude that one need be baptized but once to receive the Holy Spirit. This is the “one baptism of Eph. 4:4, and this is the meaning of Acts 2:38 where the apostle Peter tells the crowd on Pentecost to “Repent and be baptized everyone of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and you shall receive the gift of he Holy Spirit.” This is similar to 2 Cor. 1:21-22 in that multiple promises are made: not only the forgiveness of sins but also the gift of the Holy Spirit. Reason demands that we conclude that one receives the Spirit when he receives the forgiveness of sins.

How many times did those on Pentecost have to be baptized for the forgiveness of sins? The same number as for receiving the Holy Spirit!

There is no evidence in Scripture that those who were once baptized in water were ever urged to be baptized a second time — this time “Spirit baptism” — in order to receive the Spirit. If this were an experience in the early church, we could expect various urgings and entreaties regarding a second baptism whereby the Spirit would come into their hearts. To the contrary we find language such as Acts 5:32: God gives the Holy Spirit to all those who obey Him. He doesn’t say that we are to long for, pray for, “be anxious” for the Holy Spirit. It is simply that we are to obey God and he will give us the Holy Spirit. This is so generally the case in Scripture that there is the suggestion that God is so faithful to give the Spirit to those who obey him that believers might have the Holy Spirit and not know it. Such as in 1 Cor. 6:19: “Do you not know that your body is the temple of the Holy Spirit who is in you, whom you have from God, and you are not your own?”

This verse shows that believers may have the Holy Spirit and not even know it. We can only conclude that the Corinthians received the Spirit when they believed and were baptized (Acts 18:8). Just as one may be rich and not realize it, he may have the Holy Spirit and not realize it. And so Paul is urging them to make more of a blessing they already have. Conspicuously absent is any urging from the apostle to “get the second blessing” or “be baptized with the Holy Spirit” or whatever. The Corinthians were baptized but once, at which time they received the Spirit.

There are two irregularities in Scripture in reference to this subject that should be noted, irregular in the sense that they do not follow the sequence implied in the above Scriptures: faith, baptism, Holy Spirit.

One is in Acts 8 in the case of the Samaritans, who believed and were baptized (verse 12), but who did not receive the Holy Spirit. That the record would emphasize this is another indication that the usual order was faith, baptism, Holy Spirit. But here we have the unusual in that people are baptized but do not receive the Spirit. The story goes on to reveal that apostles go to Samaria to correct the situation. They lay their hands on the baptized believers and they receive the Holy Spirit (verse 17). So in Samaria we have an exceptional order: faith, baptism — a time sequence — laying on of hands, Holy Spirit. We have no way of knowing for sure why the Samaritans did not receive the Spirit when they were baptized. Even Luke the historian, as he tells the story, implies that they should have. The apostles correct the situation by the laying on of hands, not by urging upon them some kind of second baptism of the Spirit.

It would be reasonable to conclude that something went wrong in Samaria, obstructing the usual process, such as a defective faith. In any event the exception does not control the rule but the rule controls the exception. The rule is faith, baptism, Holy Spirit, and that is why Paul asked an itinerant band of disciples, “Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed?” (Acts 19:2). When they answered in the negative the apostle knew something was wrong, and the question he poses goes far in sub staining the point of this article, “Into what then were you baptized?” The apostle saw the one baptism into Christ as the means of receiving the Spirit.

If it was unthinkable to Paul that one would be a baptized believer and yet not have the Holy Spirit, why should it not be to us? Then why all this talk about “Holy Spirit baptism” as a means of receiving the Spirit, perhaps many years after one has been baptized into Christ?

The other exception to the order is in Acts 10 at the house of Cornelius where the order is faith, Holy Spirit, baptism. Here they receive the Spirit when they believe (or while hearing the word). This situation provides one of the strongest testimonials for the place of baptism, for if ever baptism could be passed over as of only minor significance it would be here with people who had already received the Holy Spirit. And so there was cause for the question, “Can anyone forbid water, that these should not be baptized who have received the Holy Spirit just as we have?” (verse 47) The apostle Peter’s response is remarkable: “He commanded them to be baptized in the name of the Lord.” This should lay to rest forever any claim that baptism isn’t all that significant. Even those who had already received the Holy Spirit were commanded by an apostle to be baptized.

This exception hardly affects my argument that a believer need be baptized but once to receive the Spirit, for at the house of Cornelius they received the Spirit before they were baptized even once. But they were baptized once at an apostle’s command.

These exceptions should cause us to be slow about putting God in a box and dictating what he will do and not do. As with his mercy. he will give his Spirit to whom he will, and we can nail down no precise order that has no exceptions.

But we can identify what usually took place in the early church. All believers received the Holy Spirit, and in this order: faith, repentance, baptism, Holy Spirit, usually.

More important by far than the when was the fact of the Spirit’s presence. The Spirit impelled and empowered them, so that Paul would eventually equate the kingdom of God itself to the fact: “The kingdom of God is not food and drink, but righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit” (Rom. 14:17).

What matters to us today is that the Holy Spirit is God’s gift to all who trust and obey him. This truth should not be distorted by the misconception that the sealing, filling, drinking, receiving or baptism of Spirit is some kind of “second blessing” or “second baptism” for few who become privileged citizens in the kingdom. Once the church taps that great resource of power that God has given to all his children we will once more make it evident that the true Body of Christ upon earth is Spirit-filled and power-filled. To be once baptized is quite adequate for all blessings that are in Christ. It is often a matter of what God did for us when we believed and obeyed the gospel in washing of regeneration.” Some of us may be like the man who lived all his life in poverty atop a gold mine and never knew it. —the Editor